COMMA Network

Networking Ministries to Muslims in North America

  • HOME
  • Calendar of Events
  • CONTACT US
  • LINKS
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • History of COMMA
    • COMMA Local Groups
  • Resources
    • Ministry Resources
      • Books
        • Muslim Evangelism
        • Testimonies
      • Jesus Film DVDs
      • Bibles
      • World Relief Resources
      • Tracts
      • Discipleship Resources
      • Recursos en Espanol
      • Farsi Language Resources
      • Prayer
    • Online Resources
      • Apps
      • Booklets
      • Other Online Resources
    • Muslim Ministry DVDs
    • Training Centers / Programs
  • Approaches
    • Overcoming Fear of Muslims
    • Building Friendships with Muslims
    • Equip Your Church to Reach Muslims
    • 7 Approaches to Muslims
    • Types of Muslims in the Modern World: The Many Voices of Islam
    • Testimonies
    • Islam in North America
    • Campus Ministry
    • Ministry of Hospitality
    • Muslim Women
    • Keys to the Iranian Heart
    • African American Muslims
    • Does Goodness Live In You?
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Members

Was Mecca Islam’s Birthplace—or Petra?

October 24, 2018 By Malik Ibrahim

Tweet

By Mark Anderson

All Muslims believe Muhammad* received his first divine revelations in Mecca and consider the city’s Kaaba the “House of God.” The Qur’an says Abraham and his son Ishmael built the Kaaba (Q 22:26-29), though many Muslims believe Adam and Eve built the original. Either way, all Muslims believe their cube-like shrine was a pagan temple before Muhammad* cleansed it of its idols. They prostrate themselves toward it five times daily in prayer. And they ritually circle it—if possible, touching or kissing its sacred Black Stone—on pilgrimage.

In the 1970s, however, John Wansbrough, Patricia Crone and other scholars challenged the traditional view. They argued that Islam evolved over two centuries not in Mecca, but in the Fertile Crescent—in Nabatea or Mesopotamia.

Read the rest of the article here.

Filed Under: History, Islam, Muhammad, Scholarship Tagged With: archeology, Mecca, origin of Islam, Petra

Search

About Us

  • What is COMMA
    • COMMA Local Groups
  • History of COMMA
  • Contact Us

Resources

  • Books
  • Testimonial Books
  • Evangelism Books
  • Booklets
  • Tracts
  • Recursos en Espanol
  • Jesus Film DVDs
  • Muslim Ministry DVDs
  • Farsi Language Resources
  • Bibles
  • Prayer
  • World Relief Resources
  • Other Online Resources
  • Training Centers / Programs
  • Lausanne Recommendations

COMMA

COMMA is a coalition of Christian agencies that network together to reach and disciple Muslims in North America.

COMMA exists to

  • Network
  • Equip
  • Teach

Recent posts

  • Turkey to deport American Islamic State detainee after Greece slams door
  • American-Born Woman Who Joined ISIS Is Not a Citizen, Judge Rules
  • Mary vs. Aminah: Why Did Allah So Honor Mary, the Mother of Jesus? Tawhid Dilemma Ep. 9

Resources

  • Books
  • Testimonial Books
  • Evangelism Books
  • Booklets
  • Tracts
  • Recursos en Espanol
  • Jesus Film DVDs
  • Muslim Ministry DVDs
  • Farsi Language Resources
  • Bibles
  • Prayer
  • World Relief Resources
  • Other Online Resources
  • Training Centers / Programs
  • Lausanne Recommendations

Approaches to Muslims

  • Campus Ministry
  • 7 Approaches to Muslims
  • Keys to the Iranian Heart
  • Ministry of Hospitality
  • Muslim Women
  • Sharing Christ with African American Muslims

Categories

  • Ahmadiya Islam
  • American Islam
  • Apologetics
  • Asylum
  • Believer from a Muslim Background
  • Book Reviews
  • Burka
  • Community
  • Converts
  • Culture
  • Demographics
  • Diaspora
  • Discipleship
  • Donation
  • Dreams
  • Europe
  • Evangelism
  • Family
  • Fasting
  • Folk Islam
  • Hajj
  • Hijab
  • History
  • Holidays
  • Hospitality
  • Immigrant
  • Immigration
  • Insider Movement
  • Interfaith Dialogue
  • Iran
  • Islam
  • Islamic Reform
  • Islamophobia
  • Jesus
  • Latino Islam
  • Marriage
  • Mecca
  • Mosque
  • Muhammad
  • Nation of Islam
  • Persecuted Church
  • Politics
  • Prayer
  • Qibla
  • Qur'an
  • Radical Islam
  • Ramadan
  • Refugees
  • Scholarship
  • Scripture
  • Second Generation
  • Sects
  • Shari'a
  • Shiite
  • Slavery
  • Social Media
  • Terrorism
  • Testimony
  • Theology
  • Uncategorized
  • Women