COMMA Network

Networking Ministries to Muslims in North America

  • HOME
  • Calendar of Events
  • CONTACT US
  • LINKS
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • History of COMMA
    • COMMA Local Groups
  • Resources
    • Ministry Resources
      • Books
        • Muslim Evangelism
        • Testimonies
      • Jesus Film Project: Free Tools for Evangelism
      • Bibles
      • World Relief Resources
      • Tracts
      • Discipleship Resources
      • Recursos en Espanol
      • Farsi Language Resources
      • Prayer
    • Online Resources
      • Apps
      • Booklets
      • COMMA Network YouTube
      • Other Online Resources
    • Muslim Ministry DVDs
    • Training Centers / Programs
  • Approaches
    • Overcoming Fear of Muslims
    • Building Friendships with Muslims
    • Equip Your Church to Reach Muslims
    • 7 Approaches to Muslims
    • Types of Muslims in the Modern World: The Many Voices of Islam
    • Testimonies
    • Islam in North America
    • Campus Ministry
    • Ministry of Hospitality
    • Muslim Women
    • Keys to the Iranian Heart
    • African American Muslims
    • Does Goodness Live In You?
  • Editorials
  • Articles
  • Members

Why Muslims Celebrate a Jewish Holiday

October 30, 2015 By COMMA Network

By Haroon Moghul

(CNN)Muslims will be fasting this Friday. It’s Ashura, the 10th day of the first month on the Islamic calendar. Islamic tradition holds that the Prophet Mohammed encountered Jews fasting on this day, who told them they were marking the Hebrews escape from Egypt, and he decided to join them.

While the Islamic tradition teaches the Exodus occurred on Yom Kippur (in Judaism, the day of atonement) Jews actually commemorate the Hebrews’ escape from Egypt on Passover.

If you’re wondering why Muslims would celebrate a Jewish holiday, that’s because neither Mohammed nor the early Muslims saw themselves as part of a new faith community.

They were a reboot, the restoration of monotheism to its original factory settings. Mohammed described himself as concluding the line of prophecy that went way back to Adam in the Garden of Eden and includes Noah and Abraham. Moses and Jesus, too: They’re named much more often in the Quran than Mohammed is.

Ashura also has another, grimmer meaning for Muslims: it marks the day the Prophet Mohammed’s grandson was killed after a failed uprising against a corrupt caliph.

For Sunni Muslims, that event was a tragedy. For Shia Muslims, it’s even worse: The family of the Prophet was denied its right to lead, but this time by blood and sword. So this Friday is, for all Muslims, a day of deliverance and a day of sorrow, of freedom — and tyranny.

After the Prophet Mohammed’s death in 632, his closest companions struggled to keep control of his community. Shia Muslims believe his cousin, Ali, was meant to be the first ruler; the majority went with the Prophet’s father-in-law, Abu Bakr.

Despite the dispute, Islam was surging so quickly that soon the old believers were overwhelmed by a surge of new converts, all of whom came for different reasons. Piety, maybe. But also prestige and power.

Forty years after Mohammed passed on, a king ruled in the guise of a Caliph, arrogating himself to powers Muslims judged pharaoh-like. (There’s no greater Quranic symbol of tyranny than Moses’ nemesis.)

Rather than rule in a simple, egalitarian fashion, like his predecessors and the Prophet whose memory was still alive and well, the fifth caliph, Muawiya, built palaces and shut himself off from his people.

To add insult to injury, he appointed his own son, Yazid, to succeed him on his death. Click here to read the rest of the article Muslims Celebrate Jewish Holiday

Filed Under: History Tagged With: CNN, Holiday, Jews, Muslims, Yom Kippur

Search

About Us

  • What is COMMA
    • COMMA Local Groups
  • History of COMMA
  • Contact Us

Resources

  • Books
  • Testimonial Books
  • Evangelism Books
  • Booklets
  • Tracts
  • Recursos en Espanol
  • Jesus Film Project: Free Tools for Evangelism
  • Muslim Ministry DVDs
  • Farsi Language Resources
  • Bibles
  • Prayer
  • World Relief Resources
  • Other Online Resources
  • Training Centers / Programs
  • Lausanne Recommendations
  • COMMA Network YouTube

COMMA

COMMA is a coalition of Christian agencies that network together to reach and disciple Muslims in North America.

COMMA exists to

  • Network
  • Equip
  • Teach

Recent posts

  • Turkey to deport American Islamic State detainee after Greece slams door
  • American-Born Woman Who Joined ISIS Is Not a Citizen, Judge Rules
  • Mary vs. Aminah: Why Did Allah So Honor Mary, the Mother of Jesus? Tawhid Dilemma Ep. 9

Resources

  • Books
  • Testimonial Books
  • Evangelism Books
  • Booklets
  • Tracts
  • Recursos en Espanol
  • Jesus Film Project: Free Tools for Evangelism
  • Muslim Ministry DVDs
  • Farsi Language Resources
  • Bibles
  • Prayer
  • World Relief Resources
  • Other Online Resources
  • Training Centers / Programs
  • Lausanne Recommendations
  • COMMA Network YouTube

Approaches to Muslims

  • Campus Ministry
  • 7 Approaches to Muslims
  • Keys to the Iranian Heart
  • Ministry of Hospitality
  • Muslim Women
  • Sharing Christ with African American Muslims

Categories

  • Ahmadiya Islam
  • American Islam
  • Apologetics
  • Asylum
  • Believer from a Muslim Background
  • Book Reviews
  • Burka
  • Community
  • Converts
  • Culture
  • Demographics
  • Diaspora
  • Discipleship
  • Donation
  • Dreams
  • Europe
  • Evangelism
  • Family
  • Fasting
  • Folk Islam
  • Hajj
  • Hijab
  • History
  • Holidays
  • Hospitality
  • Immigrant
  • Immigration
  • Insider Movement
  • Interfaith Dialogue
  • Iran
  • Islam
  • Islamic Reform
  • Islamophobia
  • Jesus
  • Latino Islam
  • Marriage
  • Mecca
  • Mosque
  • Muhammad
  • Nation of Islam
  • Persecuted Church
  • Politics
  • Prayer
  • Qibla
  • Qur'an
  • Radical Islam
  • Ramadan
  • Refugees
  • Scholarship
  • Scripture
  • Second Generation
  • Sects
  • Shari'a
  • Shiite
  • Slavery
  • Social Media
  • Terrorism
  • Testimony
  • Theology
  • Uncategorized
  • Women